| Past Master No. | Name | Year |
| 1-2, 4 | Thomas Allen | 1873-1874, 1876 |
| 3 | Dan Rose | 1875 |
| 5-10 | David Newton | 1877, 1882 |
| 6 | James W. Hannah | 1878 |
| 7 | James M. Glass | 1879 |
| 8-11 | William S. Evans | 1880, 1883 |
| 9 | George R. Locker | 1881 |
| 12 | W. McLean Wallbank | 1884 |
| 13 | George Nelson | 1885 |
| 14-15 | Charles W. Wellstead | 1886-1887 |
| 16 | Christopher Clift | 1888 |
| 17-18 | James McCrudden | 1889-1890 |
| 19-20 | Thomas Erskine | 1891-1892 |
| 21-22 | James Wilson | 1893-1894 |
| 23-24 | Joshua J.F. Blackie | 1895-1896 |
| 25 | James McCaw | 1897 |
| 26 | Anthony E. Sennett | 1898 |
| 27 | John J. Lomax | 1899 |
| 28-29 | George Tate | 1900-1901 |
| 30 | William Ware | 1902 |
| 31-45 | William F. Robertson | 1903, 1917 |
| 32 | John Findlay | 1904 |
| 33 | William P. Baird | 1905 |
| 34-35 | Frank E. Starke | 1906-1907 |
| 36 | John Irvine | 1908 |
| 37 | Alex Maclean | 1909 |
| 38 | Joseph W. Lippiatt | 1910 |
| 39 | William J. Wilkinson | 1911 |
| 40 | Robert Bayne | 1912 |
| 41 | John N. Robetson | 1913 |
| 42 | Alexander M. Forbes | 1914 |
| 43 | James C. Pool | 1915 |
| 44 | Charles MacD. Hight | 1916 |
| 46-49 | William E. Wesley | 1918, 1921 |
| 47 | George O. Hall | 1919 |
| 48 | Robert F. Milroy | 1920 |
| 50 | James Laird | 1922 |
| 51 | William Chalmers | 1923 |
| 52 | John Denham | 1924 |
| 53 | Stanley G. Blackie | 1925 |
| 54 | William S. MacLaren | 1926 |
| 55 | Walter S. Page | 1927 |
| 56 | Arthur R. Griffiths | 1928 |
| 57 | Sidney A. Goodwin | 1929 |
| 58 | Charles H. Pitts | 1930 |
| 59 | Alfred G. Fudge | 1931 |
| 60 | George Ritchie | 1932 |
| 61 | James S. L. Lancaster | 1933 |
| 62, 74 | Albert Halsall | 1934, 1946 |
| 63 | Harry Austin | 1935 |
| 64 | Edward D. Graham | 1936 |
| 65 | Elliot H. Jones | 1937 |
| 66 | Claude Heydenreich | 1938 |
| 67 | William D. Mein | 1939 |
| 68 | Earnest B. Fairley | 1940 |
| 69, 75 | James Ritchie | 1941, 1947 |
| 70 | Thomas H. Thoms | 1942 |
| 71 | James P. Irvine | 1943 |
| 72 | Frank R. Mills | 1944 |
| 73 | Samuel A. Davidson | 1945 |
| 76, 82 | William Stevenson | 1948, 1954 |
| 77 | Lloyd B. Whelan | 1949 |
| 78 | Garfield F. Bryan | 1950 |
| 79 | Nelson W. Brown | 1951 |
| 80 | Walter H.G. Smith | 1952 |
| 81 | Robert Abbott | 1953 |
| 83 | Hugh G. Brown | 1955 |
| 84 | Charles S. Jarvis | 1956 |
| 85 | John Tempest | 1957 |
| 86 | Earl R. Wheeler | 1958 |
| 87, 96 | Kenneth Foster | 1959, 1968 |
| 88 | James C. Grundy | 1960 |
| 89 | Norman G. Nicholson | 1961 |
| 90 | Norman G. Stanley | 1962 |
| 91 | George W. Sutton | 1963 |
| 92 | Donald F. Plant | 1964 |
| 93 | Herbert W. Halsall | 1965 |
| 94, 99 | James H. Young | 1966, 1971 |
| 95 | James F. Barlett | 1967 |
| 97 | Thomas Burnside | 1969 |
| 98 | Earle F. Walker | 1970 |
| 100, 111 | George P. Crozier | 1972, 1983 |
| 101 | Allan G. Baird | 1973 |
| 102 | James J. Wardle | 1974 |
| 103 | Hector Young | 1975 |
| 104 | Edward H. Birch | 1976 |
| 105 | Robert Humble | 1977 |
| 106 | Lionel L. Coates | 1978 |
| 107 | Robert P. Abbott | 1979 |
| 108 | Colin C. Abbott | 1980 |
| 109 | Robert Newman | 1981 |
| 110-112 | Robert C. McCracken | 1982, 1984 |
| 113 | Armand J. Lono | 1985 |
| 114 | Douglas A. Dobby | 1986 |
| 115-116, 150-151 | Stephen R. Coull | 1987-88, 2022-23 |
| 117 | Graham R. Foster | 1989 |
| 118-119 | Keith R. Bussey | 1990-1991 |
| 120 | Peter J. Snickars | 1992 |
| 121 | John D. Dobby | 1993 |
| 122 | Iain M. MacLeod | 1994 |
| 123, 138 | Stephen D. Martin | 1995, 2010 |
| 124 | Jean-Guy Ratelle | 1996 |
| 125 | Geoffrey H. Cockerell | 1997 |
| 126 | Carmine Lisio | 1998 |
| 127 | Ronald G. Baylis | 1999 |
| 128-129 | Richard Frontczak | 2000-2001 |
| 130, 132 | R.R. McConnell | 2002, 2004 |
| 131 | K.W. Drummond | 2003 |
| 133-134, 139 | Norman Dero | 2005-2006, 2011 |
| 135 | Edward Lyon | 2007 |
| 136-137 | David L. O. Faure | 2008-2009 |
| 140-141 | Mathieu Robert | 2012-2013 |
| 142-144 | Patrick Dero | 2014-2016 |
| 145-149 | Karim Rahill | 2017-2021 |
